To turn doctoral students into independent researchers, curriculum reform is particularly important for higher education. Since doctoral students now have diverse academic backgrounds, they enter research training with different levels of expertise and skill.
Some doctor of philosophy (PhD) students might have a strong research background, such as master of philosophy degrees and journal publications, while some professional doctorate students, such as doctor of education (EdD) students, might not have practised English-language academic writing for several years since their taught master’s programmes.
- How to shape part-time doctoral identities: a guide for supervisors
- I was an expert in my field. Then I became a beginner again
- ‘The first step is to understand what supervisors and students need’
Nevertheless, we expect students in both programmes to produce high-quality research following rigorous academic training. Qibang participated in an academic exchange programme with the University of British Columbia (UBC), which included travelling to Canada to experience a few weeks of a course called Academic Writing for Publication.
Drawing on doctoral students’ experiences from courses at both universities and communicating with the lecturers at UBC, Qibang Su held in-depth discussions with co-author Zhenzhou Zhao, who is an experienced doctoral supervisor and oversees several specialised doctoral-level courses at the Education University of Hong Kong.
Here, we offer three reflections on the design of research-oriented doctoral courses.
Three practical ways to realise semi-independent research training
1. Guidance: balance between independent research and teacher-led instruction
At our university, first-year doctoral students either take a teacher-led course, similar to undergraduate or taught master’s degree courses, or an independent research-focused course – much like an undergraduate’s final project or the dissertation in the master’s programme.
Although both approaches are rational, tailoring support to students’ backgrounds can enhance their success – whether they are transitioning to research for the first time or building on experience. Drawing inspiration from the academic writing programme at UBC, we discovered an excellent way to harmonise these two pathways.
For some taught modules, the slides are available online in advance. Students choose whether to attend class or conduct research elsewhere, such as the library, based on their self-assessment. This curriculum design is effective because both learners and educators can spend their time more productively. Some students no longer need to study content they have already mastered, while teachers can focus their energy on fewer students who need more basic guidance.
2. Flexibility: supporting different topics and stages of research
At our university, specialised courses for first-year doctoral students are always led by relevant experts, such as research area coordinators. Students are encouraged to begin a research project with the literature review because they are assumed to be beginners in a specific area.
In contrast, the academic writing programme at UBC is designed more flexibly. The key lecturer is an expert in language education, with a focus on qualitative research, and is also familiar with broader research fields. He allowed the students to choose any research topic across fields and at different stages, including projects involving data analysis and drafting the findings and discussion sections. In this way, doctoral students are accepted as researchers with some experience in their fields and are able to do more than just the literature review.
For instance, one doctoral student was already analysing qualitative data collected in Hong Kong as part of a supervisor-led project and received feedback from the lecturer in Canada, who held a more Western and interdisciplinary world view.
This strategy is worth considering because some doctoral students serve as part-time research assistants on their supervisors’ projects. By using course time for guidance on these ongoing projects, they have the chance to explore that subject area in greater depth, rather than writing a review paper on a topic they might struggle to develop and publish.
3. Sharing and refining the interim research outcome with the scholarly community
Both our university and UBC host academic conferences and forums open to doctoral students, and they often invite researchers at different career stages to provide feedback in parallel sessions. In addition to these sessions, a standout feature of the UBC experience is its training that guides students towards successful journal publications.
For instance, the UBC lecturer systematically teaches about journal selection strategies and how to communicate with reviewers and the editorial team. Doctoral students in related research fields, such as civic education, sociology of education and youth studies, practise acting as reviewers, making comments on their peers’ work.
Journal publication is not a requirement for graduation at our university because most doctoral students choose the traditional doctoral thesis. Yet, a few published or accepted journal papers can equip graduates for the competitive global academic job market. Embedding the relevant knowledge and skills earlier, in the first or second year, can help your students’ publications proceed more smoothly in the third and fourth years. Encourage students in similar research fields to network because it can be helpful for future co-author collaborations.
Effective doctoral learning thrives on a dynamic balance between self-directed exploration and expert mentorship, which is especially vital in the lead-up to the doctoral qualification exam. This journey is most impactful when structured as a guided, semi-independent research experience enriched by flexibility, constructive feedback and a supportive scholarly community.
Qibang Su is a doctor of education candidate, research assistant and acting teaching assistant, and Zhenzhou Zhao is associate professor of the department of curriculum and instruction at the Education University of Hong Kong.
If you would like advice and insight from academics and university staff delivered direct to your inbox each week, sign up for the Campus newsletter.
comment