Where’s our Black bereavement leave?

By dene.mullen, 23 February, 2023
Higher education routinely ignores the emotional needs of Black faculty and staff, particularly after traumatic events, and it’s time for that to change, says Angel Jones
Article type
Article
Main text

As an educator, it is my duty to provide an environment for students that is thought-provoking and soul-affirming, so I intentionally create a space that supports them holistically, not just academically. I push back against the belief that baggage should be left at the door and encourage them to bring their whole selves into the classroom. After all, ignoring the external factors that influence their internal being denies their humanity and robs them of an opportunity to be seen and appreciated for who they truly are.

One way I affirm the importance of students’ whole selves is by acknowledging the impact societal events may have on them personally and professionally. In alignment with this practice, I reached out to my students when the video of the murder of Tyre Nichols was released. As I was writing the email, my primary concern was the mental and emotional well-being of my students. However, the tears streaming down my face as I typed let me know that ignoring my own feelings was impossible – which wasn’t surprising given the numerous times I have cried while sending similar emails.

In fact, I have tears in my eyes right now just thinking about all those emails I’ve sent and all the ones I know I will have to send in the future. Despite the pain, I send them because it is my duty, because my students might need me and because if I don’t, who will? That’s not to say I’m the only person who looks out for the well-being of students, because that is far from the truth. However, history has shown us that Black educators often have to exert additional emotional energy to pick up the slack the academy leaves behind after it sends its obligatory, and often performative, statement to the campus community.  

But while those obviously copy-pasted, campus-wide emails are the bare minimum, Black faculty and staff don’t even get that. Where is the acknowledgment of our pain? Where are our counselling services? Where is our grace for missed meetings and deadlines while we mourn? Yes, we have jobs to do and students to support, but we also have trauma to process.

I am a proud educator who loves what I do. But before that, I am a Black woman. A Black woman who is expected to return to “business as usual” on Monday after seeing a member of my community murdered on Friday. Although it is customary for employees to receive support and understanding while grieving the loss of a loved one, the same care is rarely shown to the Black community when we lose someone in horrific and traumatic ways. Where’s our Black bereavement leave?

The situation often reminds me of Martin Luther King Junior’s sermon, “Remaining Awake Through a Great Revolution”. When addressing the bootstrap theory, he said: “It’s alright to tell a man to lift himself by his own bootstraps, but it is a cruel jest to say to a bootless man that he ought to lift himself by his own bootstraps.”

Pulling oneself up by the bootstraps is a privilege similar to the ability to put on one’s own mask. If cabin pressure changes on an aeroplane, oxygen masks drop from above and passengers are instructed to put them on – with a reminder to put on their own mask first before helping others. As a grieving Black educator, I would love to put on my metaphorical mask first before helping my students, but that is hard when the academy continues to leave us maskless. Which is ironic given the masks Black educators are expected to wear every day to hide who we are.

With all of this in mind, here are two key ways that universities can begin to support Black faculty and staff:

Counselling

This is an obvious, yet consistently underfunded, resource that could support Black faculty and staff who are dealing with trauma caused by racism and anti-Blackness on and off campus. Racial battle fatigue (RBF), a term coined by William Smith that refers to the psychological and physiological consequences of experiencing racism, has been well documented, yet its (sometimes deadly) symptoms continue to be minimised or ignored completely.

Psychological consequences of RBF include anxiety, depression and suicidal thoughts, while physiological consequences include elevated heart rate, tension headaches and stomach ulcers. We experience these symptoms on a regular basis as a result of our first-hand racial trauma as well as the trauma we experience when we see people such as Philando Castile, Eric Garner and Patrick Lyoya murdered on camera. Free counselling services, by culturally competent counsellors familiar with identifying and addressing RBF, should be available at all times, not just when our trauma has been televised.

Time to grieve

Some may have thought I was joking when I mentioned Black bereavement leave, but I wasn’t. We need space and time to grieve without having to explain or defend it. And since the grief process, like the Black community, is not a monolith, flexibility is required. Some may need a day off while others may just need to be able to work from home. Some may need a small extension on a deadline while others may need to have something removed from their plate completely.

This is one of the many reasons why relationship-building is important for the retention of Black faculty and staff. Having a relationship with people you claim to want to help will increase the likelihood of them feeling comfortable enough to verbalise their needs with you.

There are several ways to support Black faculty and staff, but one of the most effective is to just ask. Don’t assume you know what they want or need just because you read this article. Anti-Blackness is intentional, so your efforts to combat it must also be.  

Angel Jones is a visiting assistant professor in the department of educational leadership at Southern Illinois University – Edwardsville, US. She is also a public scholar who uses social media as an educational tool to increase access to academic scholarship, and author of Street Scholar: Using Public Scholarship to Educate, Advocate, and Liberate (Peter Lang, 2022).

If you found this interesting and want advice and insight from academics and university staff delivered direct to your inbox each week, sign up for the THE Campus newsletter.

Standfirst
Higher education routinely ignores the emotional needs of Black faculty and staff, particularly after traumatic events, and it’s time for that to change, says Angel Jones

comment5

THE_comment

1 year 10 months ago

Reported
False
User Id
3442119
User name
thebiflower
Comment body
A thought-provoking and sobering article. In a country that insists on the narrative that racism is a thing of the past, Racial Battle Fatigue is easily dismissed by the white population. As a person of Jewish descent, I feel hallowed out and grief stricken when a synagogue is attacked. Antisemitism is on the rise. But at least I do not have to witness members of my community get murdered by police on video every week. At least many of us can pass as white xtians. The Black community has a member of their community stolen from them what seems like every day, like clockwork. Thank you for voicing this need for compassion and support.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoidGhlYmlmbG93ZXIiLCJlbWFpbCI6ImRhaXN5dmNydWlzZUBnbWFpbC5jb20iLCJpZCI6IjM0NDIxMTkiLCJpYXQiOjE2NzcxMTcwNjcsImV4cCI6MTY3OTcwOTA2N30.8F4C-64XR2KqdPK6BdT0dX0mgdEmVrxdMCXMAMeemPwMd4G9PD7FlatXf5DVF5gykAyiy9ODUaBfRAC00Ki0uw
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 year 9 months ago

Reported
True
User Id
3445680
User name
harnessedlightning1
Comment body
I thought I was reading a deliberate comedy as I read this article. The author wants bereavement time off from her employment, and counseling provided to her, every time a Black person is killed regardless of whether she knew the person, and without consideration of the geographic location of the incident ? If the author applied that proposal just to the largest city in the State in which she presently teaches, she would have to be paid bereavement time continually for the dozen or more Black men murdered each weekend, almost exclusively by other Black men. How is the author intentionally creating a space that supports her students holistically and not just academically by seeking to be on permanent emotional sabbatical ? Sounds far more like a formula for lifetime welfare and grift rather than anything deserved or earned. If the author truly is so concerned about the carnage that befalls the Black community mostly by their own hands and weapons, perhaps she should re-focus her talents towards that community and the causes of the violence that decimates families in them. Someone who finds themselves in a perpetual state of mourning would be an excellent candidate for the clergy. An educator who feels so much for the plight of the world of Black people that she considers to be her community would probably better serve herself and that community by teaching elementary education in inner city schools, so as to provide tomorrow’s Black men with the intellectual tools that may provide them an alternative to activities that can get them killed. The author talks about the anxiety she has felt every time she has seen a Black man murdered by police, and for this she finds she and the rest of the Black community needs counseling services. Did it ever occur to the author that the basis for counseling is to lead the patient towards understanding the world s/he lives in through a more logic-based lens? Which begs the question of how will counseling be of help when the counselor inevitably points out that nearly every person killed by police - regardless of race since more Caucasian people are victims of death by police than any other race - would have survived the altercation by simply complying with the orders of the police, and saying four simple words: “I want a lawyer”. Is that too difficult to remember ? Perhaps to ease the author’s emotional problems she faces from the world that surrounds her, she would be wise to consider that the fastest growing economic group in America is the Black middle class. If anyone doubts this, spend some time watching television and see what economic group the majority of the commercial seek to attract to the products and services advertised. Then she should evaluate what characteristics these upwardly-mobile Black families have relied on to improve their standards of living. In almost all cases, those characteristics include a family with a mother and father in the home, a strong emphasis on the importance of education, a work ethic that recognizes that the only place success comes before work Is in the dictionary, and a devotion to saving money earned and building capital wealth that can be passed down to their children and grandchildren in the future. Lo and behold, the same formula that every immigrant group has employed to succeed in America. Rather than wallow in irrational self-pity, this author would be wise to see the part of the glass that is half full rather than half empty, and teach her students how to be on the winning side of the water, the tide of which lifts all boats together if they just get their oars in the sea.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiaGFybmVzc2VkbGlnaHRuaW5nMSIsImVtYWlsIjoiaGFybmVzc2VkbGlnaHRuaW5nMUBob3RtYWlsLmNvbSIsImlkIjoiMzQ0NTY4MCIsImlhdCI6MTY3Nzk3MDgzNCwiZXhwIjoxNjgwNTYyODM0fQ.E2iSw-qdMViePlz67kQuan3alvlURGu-yjrwrl-bGCdgGQYkoyN6GRAiTD9j30TB_mUIBG7bm5PVcJ9xO--eSg
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 year 9 months ago

Reported
False
User Id
3446012
User name
mftkv
Comment body
I visited and read Dr. Jones after reading the provocative News piece on Fox News website. It is unfortunate that Dr. Jones wrote this article/piece in very generic terms where anyone can criticize he for wanting a "bereavement leave or reprieve" every time a black or a person of color is killed on the streets either by police or an angry mob . There are News outlets out there waiting to exploit any misstep made by a colored educator and ignite our polarized society for political gains. I pray that educators use their power and platforms more carefully so that the cause they fight becomes the news and not the individual who brings the cause to the attention of others.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoibWZ0a3YiLCJlbWFpbCI6InRrLXZpbm9kQHdpdS5lZHUiLCJpZCI6IjM0NDYwMTIiLCJpYXQiOjE2NzgwNzEyNzAsImV4cCI6MTY4MDY2MzI3MH0.i5PL51IXOXgf0cuBrx5GNRk5Qh9rgszEpC3HwBHgB5_yziKNDsIJu9o4gXtlwoMUBnB4xEFDvSqgpclp6WJuPw
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 year 9 months ago

Reported
False
User Id
3446354
User name
groups_chit.02
Comment body
This crybaby. Somebody call the waaaaahmbulance
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiZ3JvdXBzX2NoaXQuMDIiLCJlbWFpbCI6Imdyb3Vwc19jaGl0LjAyQGljbG91ZC5jb20iLCJpZCI6IjM0NDYzNTQiLCJpYXQiOjE2NzgxMjk1OTcsImV4cCI6MTY4MDcyMTU5N30.mX9GkYzRz-uMAL1J1mcGWOVA9gv2gxrmj9d-Mjzbdf_KZJRfoolCFDr2aQ_s8wSGvfIAbswe3KQVEdqZbMnQuA
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 year 9 months ago

Reported
True
User Id
3446345
User name
francezcabella
Comment body
“I pray that educators use their power and platforms more carefully so that the cause they fight becomes the news.” I saw this story on an international news website and I had to check it out to see if it was real. Having studied in the US for my post-graduate degrees, I know the tension that exists between the Black communities and everyone else, and am sorry to see that your politicians chose to inflame the tensions and your academicians offer excuses rather than solutions. This story is typical of that paradigm and its saddening. The idea that anyone would pray that the cause they fight becomes news is symptomatic of the actual problem. The object of their efforts is political publicity instead of the promotion of personal responsibility, even though it’s the lack of such individual responsibility that is the cause of the problems they bemoan in American society. Never in history has any country expended so much effort and money to end the tragedy of the Black people in the United States. The American people even have accepted for half a century the distortion of their laws on discrimination to help lift their minority populations out of poverty, and many have benefitted from this opportunity. Yet what is the message that comes from the alleged representatives of the Black communities ? Is it one of gratefulness, or one of victimhood ? From afar it seems that no effort is enough for complainers who in reality are making excuses for those who either refuse or are unable to improve their plight. I live in probably the most multi-cultural city in the world, and we have our problems. But they are no where near the difficulties that seemingly never end between the Black population of the US and the rest of that country. Maybe because here in the UK, regardless of what demographic you belong, whining is not an accepted way of social comport. Our politicians are chastised rather than rewarded should they pander for votes by promising ever greater unearned benefits. We offer the ungrateful who have been given benefit a swift kick in the hind quarters or quick passage out of our country. Because there is no greater cancer on a country than that of leeches who refuse to help themselves.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiZnJhbmNlemNhYmVsbGEiLCJlbWFpbCI6ImZyYW5jZXpjYWJlbGxhQHlhaG9vLmNvLnVrIiwiaWQiOiIzNDQ2MzQ1IiwiaWF0IjoxNjc4MTMxNTEzLCJleHAiOjE2ODA3MjM1MTN9.rWJUNaU0fT6ICGH0UpUxGsmxZsn3vovksNXuETk5olBx6Z2CWx9NYOK9DkrwNxv94cOYEEhQkis1VNVbyVBr_w
Reviewed
On