What is student engagement?

By dene.mullen, 7 May, 2024
The move online compounded matters, but even before that, nobody could agree on what student engagement was – and that needs to change, says Chris Headleand
Article type
Article
Main text

About two years ago, I attended a teaching conference where one of the headline sessions was a debate: two people arguing for and against the concept of student engagement. After 20 years of teaching, I had not heard a convincing argument against student engagement, so I was keen to listen to a new perspective.

It soon became clear that the speakers had defined student engagement very differently, which was at the core of their differing viewpoints. This confusion was compounded during the question-and-answer session. Almost everyone raising a question seemed to have come to the debate with their own unique and contradictory definition. As such, the discussion didn’t go anywhere, as each new speaker just added more confounding variables that didn’t advance the narrative. It was undoubtedly one of the more confusing academic exchanges I have ever participated in.

We probably should have expected this confusion. Student engagement is a term used regularly but often in a way devoid of context. There is a significant body of teaching advice arguing that we should strive for student engagement, often without explaining why. The UK’s Office for Students even included “student engagement” as one of the key assessment themes in its teaching excellence framework. But again, the context around what that meant was (at best) nebulous and inconsistent. You may be thinking: “I know what student engagement is.” But I would encourage you to ask a colleague or student what they think and see how their answer differs from yours.

What is student engagement?

With the lack of a clear definition, most educators have created their own meanings, but these vary wildly. I recently launched a survey that asked: how do you define student engagement? About 200 current and former staff and students responded.

Students often focused on areas of representation, such as “asking our opinions” or “involving us in how the university is run”. Staff responses were significantly more varied. Everything from “ensuring students attend lectures” to more radical or even Marxist approaches to education were included as answers. Every response in the survey covered a unique definition – which shouldn’t be the case for a core activity to which all institutions commit. 

Some have tried to address this. There are examples where universities have focused on a particular subset of student-engagement activities. “Student partners” and similar variations on the term have promised something distinct, but in many cases these initiatives often drift over time and soon represent the same problem: an endeavour becomes branding that gets applied to anything and thus loses specific meaning.

As a sector, we need to decide where we will set the bar. At what point does an activity become an example of student engagement? Most people would probably agree that attendance and engagement are two separate concepts. But based on my survey, this is not true for all. There is also confusion between “student engagement” as a concept and “engaged students” as an outcome.

To use a cooking analogy, if we make a dish, an “engaged diner” would be focused on the meal and the dining experience. As chefs, we have prepared something they enjoy, and they are motivated to eat it. By comparison, “diner engagement” would be inviting the diner to join you in the kitchen, asking them to help you plan the meal, maybe getting their tasting notes as you prepare the dish and perhaps even giving them access to the spatula.

An engaged student demonstrates interest, motivation and attention. Whereas student engagement is about involving students in learning.

I’ve always considered student engagement to be encouraging and facilitating participation from students in activities beyond the baseline expectations of their course – specifically, anything that encourages students to participate in activities outside the threshold standard that we would expect of any learner. This engagement could include governance, feedback, quality assurance, peer support, mentoring or any other activities beyond the immediate scope of a student’s studies.

But this clearly isn’t how everyone understands the term. One definition that emerged from my survey was “anything that gets students to attend their lectures”. I’m not trying to suggest that one definition is correct and the other is wrong – but the disconnect between the two makes meaningful conversations on the topic challenging.

Plus, confusion about what we mean by engagement seems to have grown among staff and students as the sector has pivoted online. For many, this new environment presented new challenges in motivating participation, and this has been the focus of the engagement conversation for the past year. Searching for “student engagement” on Twitter highlights significant discussion around synchronous attendance and comparatively little about engaging students meaningfully in learning. It isn’t uncommon to see engagement conflated with attendance, and the pivot online seems to have further highlighted this issue.

Blended learning will probably become more significant in universities moving forward, and engaging students in the design, delivery and governance of their learning will be increasingly important as we navigate this next phase of HE. It’s also entirely possible that there will be increased interest in measuring and reporting student engagement at the national level.

However, to have meaningful discussions about student engagement, we need to start with a shared lexicon. Co-developing this nomenclature with staff and students is the best way to advance our shared understanding and ensure we speak the same language. It’s hard for people to know how to achieve a goal if everyone interprets that goal differently.

Chris Headleand is director of teaching and learning for the School of Computer Science at the University of Lincoln.

Standfirst
The move online compounded matters, but even before that, nobody could agree on what student engagement was – and that needs to change, says Chris Headleand

comment5

THE_comment

3 years 6 months ago

Reported
True
User Id
1538409
User name
t_g_mercer_hull_ac_uk
Comment body
Great article Chris
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoidF9nX21lcmNlcl9odWxsX2FjX3VrIiwiZW1haWwiOiJ0LmcubWVyY2VyQGh1bGwuYWMudWsiLCJpZCI6IjE1Mzg0MDkiLCJpYXQiOjE2MjI3NTM1NDcsImV4cCI6MTYyNTM0NTU0N30.ZQCov4gqzTpSS26b2BR-MAtBRlgYuDCt-ZOVr8EYXcAp0Zbryrp3J335IpmDLoQ0mU7tkN11bJ9Ok6FW7KHR9g
Reviewed
On
User

THE_comment

2 months ago

Reported
False
User Id
3639778
User name
Juan Gonzalo
Comment body
A mi concepto el estudiante debería participar asistiendo puntualmente a las clases y participando al termino de ellas sobre que partes de esta no entendió o solicite una ampliación de la explicación para después en algún momento evaluar a su docente en relación a lo que aprendió con el y aportando sobre que sistema de gestión de aprendizaje serian los mas apropiados, toda ves que ellos viven inmersos en ellos
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiSnVhbiBHb256YWxvIiwiZW1haWwiOiJqcGFycmVubzE4NEBnbWFpbC5jb20iLCJpZCI6IjM2Mzk3NzgiLCJpYXQiOjE3Mjk0NjI0MzIsImV4cCI6MTczMjA1NDQzMn0.vAs-bNrrl8P68w5dwoaIg-9bd9uf0s0_3MUzamwnB1PVLvgaLkxTPKiFIkFzfz8ttJvNHe3VtzEChjgkSbDa9Q
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

2 months ago

Reported
False
User Id
3532145
User name
pelagia.villarreal
Comment body
El compromiso estudiantil es la dedicación, esfuerzo y participación activa que un estudiante muestra en su proceso de aprendizaje. Se refleja en su involucramiento tanto dentro como fuera del aula, su disposición para asumir responsabilidades académicas y su motivación para alcanzar sus objetivos tantos personales como laborales. Este compromiso no solo implica cumplir con las tareas y asistencias, sino también la capacidad de colaborar con compañeros, participar en actividades extracurriculares y mantener una actitud proactiva frente a los desafíos. Un estudiante comprometido está dispuesto a aprender de manera autónoma, a ser parte de la comunidad educativa y a contribuir a su propio desarrollo, así como al de su entorno.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoicGVsYWdpYS52aWxsYXJyZWFsIiwiZW1haWwiOiJwZWxhZ2lhLnZpbGxhcnJlYWxAdXdpZW5lci5lZHUucGUiLCJpZCI6IjM1MzIxNDUiLCJpYXQiOjE3Mjk1MzYwNTIsImV4cCI6MTczMjEyODA1Mn0.U6IONg0MrhHuFMryzKNCiQJi4ob21khCBVfJ_99EZ-KB9IJdBHEOYAiyxNuH16rcy8epVBosObFO_VgCVuUhbw
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 month 3 weeks ago

Reported
True
User Id
3604995
User name
israelgambini
Comment body
Para mí, 'student engagement' significa la participación activa y comprometida de los estudiantes en su propio proceso de aprendizaje. Esto va más allá de simplemente estar presente en clase; implica que los estudiantes se involucren con el material, participen en discusiones, hagan preguntas, compartan sus ideas y se sientan responsables de su propio aprendizaje. La importancia del 'student engagement' radica en que impulsa un aprendizaje más profundo y significativo. Cuando los estudiantes están comprometidos, son más propensos a recordar la información, a desarrollar habilidades de pensamiento crítico y a aplicar lo que aprenden en la vida real. Además, un ambiente de aprendizaje donde los estudiantes se sienten involucrados y valorados fomenta la motivación intrínseca, la creatividad y la colaboración. En resumen, el 'student engagement' es fundamental para crear un entorno educativo efectivo y enriquecedor, donde los estudiantes se convierten en participantes activos y responsables de su propio desarrollo.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiaXNyYWVsZ2FtYmluaSIsImVtYWlsIjoiaXNyYWVsZ2FtYmluaUBtYWlsLmNvbSIsImlkIjoiMzYwNDk5NSIsImlhdCI6MTczMDUyNDc5MSwiZXhwIjoxNzMzMTE2NzkxfQ.7Q6hCLzgUZ7wCCX4GtkAcv-L9mdjB3GnKewqX-icryTMW7YZXFsO-DmRaIE7maFsfRu978yt3Od4PMQst3sH2g
Reviewed
On

THE_comment

1 month 2 weeks ago

Reported
False
User Id
3527664
User name
jose.molina
Comment body
de manera integral lo que implica el compromiso estudiantil, destacando que va más allá de las simples tareas académicas y la asistencia a clase. Resalta la importancia de la participación activa tanto dentro como fuera del aula, la disposición para asumir responsabilidades académicas y el enfoque hacia el logro de metas personales y profesionales. Además, menciona aspectos clave como la colaboración con los compañeros, la participación en actividades extracurriculares y la actitud proactiva frente a los desafíos, los cuales son cruciales para un aprendizaje completo y significativo. El estudiante comprometido no solo busca el cumplimiento de las expectativas, sino que también tiene una actitud de aprendizaje autónomo y contribuye al desarrollo de la comunidad educativa. Este compromiso es fundamental para el éxito académico y para formar individuos capaces de afrontar y superar obstáculos, lo que también puede tener un impacto positivo en su entorno social y laboral. En resumen, el compromiso estudiantil es un componente esencial para el desarrollo integral del estudiante, y promoverlo en el aula es clave para garantizar una experiencia educativa enriquecedora y efectiva.
jwt token
eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiJ9.eyJuYW1lIjoiam9zZS5tb2xpbmEiLCJlbWFpbCI6Impvc2UubW9saW5hQHdpZW5lci5lZHUucGUiLCJpZCI6IjM1Mjc2NjQiLCJpYXQiOjE3MzEzNzg2OTcsImV4cCI6MTczMzk3MDY5N30.9Ij2O3TrqB3AGFYBrRn6BqcmuGjiTVhZR7tD2otP0kxOlhQGh3WbsPHIYLHdIuylwLsSk49zV4JnY4bxBsYwkQ
Reviewed
On