Primary tabs

How to teach the whole room rather than just the confident few

By kiera.obrien , 16 November, 2026
Inclusive teaching means understanding who is in the room and creating the conditions for every student to contribute. Fatema Jahan offers practical steps
Article type
Article
Main text

A student once provided feedback on my module that stopped me cold: “Staff is biased. We are expecting better staff member in future [sic].” My first reaction was to feel wounded. My second was to accept that the student had a point. 

Unintentionally, I had been rewarding the same handful of confident students who always volunteered to speak, while the rest of the room stayed silent. Whether they felt overlooked, uncertain or were reluctant to put themselves forward, I had not created enough ways for them to participate.

I teach gender, representative bureaucracy and social policy to more than 80 Master of Public Administration students from several countries. Some have worked for international organisations; others are studying at a Western university for the first time. Some will go on to become public servants, where listening to different perspectives and exercising judgement are part of the job. That is why it matters whose voices are heard in the classroom. Left alone, the confident voices take over.

It begins with empathy and psychological safety

Years of working in a subject make it difficult to remember what encountering its concepts for the first time feels like. I realised that I had designed parts of the syllabus around my own familiarity with the material rather than my students’ starting points and could too easily read difficulty as disengagement.

Empathy is understanding the student’s starting point, the heart of what is now called compassionate teaching. When students told me that some seminars felt rushed and the theory overwhelmed them, empathy meant planning around what they could take in, not how much I could pour out.

Empathy makes room for the thing that changes a classroom most: psychological safety. In a room that feels safe, students share what they really think. In one that does not, silence feels safer and you never hear their best thinking.

So, on day one, before I teach anything, I set the ground rules aloud: every idea and every example from your own country is welcome; getting something wrong is part of learning and no one is ridiculed, judged or mocked. That permission to speak can be a game changer.

Here are seven practical changes I have made.

  • Provide the question first. Students see the question before they respond and talk it through in a small group before anyone speaks to the whole room. Nobody is put on the spot.
  • Use names, but not to catch people out. I carry a printed register and use it sitting with a group, not calling across the room. Saying someone’s name shows I know who they are, which matters more than putting them on the spot.
  • Shrink the audience. I stopped asking students to present to the whole room and instead sit with each small group for a few minutes. In my own informal observations, that one change widened participation from a handful of regular contributors to almost the entire class.
  • Treat students as experts. Students might bring professional, cultural and institutional knowledge that you do not possess. Create opportunities for them to contribute it, without expecting anyone to speak for an entire country or culture.
  • Decolonise the syllabus. Review whose research, institutions and experiences are treated as the norm. Replace familiar Western examples with comparative ones from students’ own regions; this costs nothing but attention.
  • Use student feedback as evidence. Treat it as data for reflection, not as criticism. Let it change one thing in your teaching.
  • Follow up outside class. A short email, or a word after the seminar to check on a quiet student, matters as much as anything said in the room.

What students wrote at the end of that module told me more than the ratings did. One described it as a safe and inclusive space for discussing gender. Another said the class discussions gave diverse perspectives room to come through.

Map your classroom, then change one thing

Before changing how you teach, it helps to see it clearly. I use two simple activities.

First, map it. Draw two columns: on the left, write who your students are (nationality, language, educational background, professional experience, confidence), using only what they have chosen to share rather than what you assume. On the right, write how you teach: participation expectations, assessment types, curriculum content, the examples you use. Then ask: who does my current approach work well for, and who might find it more difficult to participate?

What surprised me was how little I knew about the people I was teaching. One student told me it was not her gender but her accent that held her back. That gave me a fresh understanding of the barriers some students face.

Second, redesign one thing. Take one activity, topic or assessment and run it through three questions.

  • Inclusion: whose voices does this bring in?
  • Decolonising: does it move beyond Western-centric defaults and can students bring their own context?
  • Engagement and safety: does it support everyone’s participation and does it feel safe?

The aim is not a curriculum overhaul but one concrete change you can make next week.

Check whether the change worked

Making the change is only half of it. Afterwards, I watch for students who are speaking now but didn’t before, and notice who is still quiet. This helps me judge whether the change reached the students it was intended to support. 

I also ask a colleague to sit in: a peer observing my class noticed that one activity drew students into conversation with me but not with each other, something I had never seen from the front of the room.

Then I read the next round of feedback with open eyes. Mine still tells me some topics feel rushed and that students want more discussion. The point is not to arrive somewhere but to keep noticing.

Start with one question

Design your next module around who your students are, what interests them and the pace and support they need to engage with the material, not only around how much you know.

Then ask yourself: who is not speaking in your classroom, and why? Sit with the answer honestly. Change one thing. That is enough to begin.

Fatema Jahan is lecturer in public administration at the University of the West of Scotland.

If you would like advice and insight from academics and university staff delivered direct to your inbox each week, sign up for the Campus newsletter.

Standfirst
Inclusive teaching means understanding who is in the room and creating the conditions for every student to contribute. Fatema Jahan offers practical steps

comment